Home › Sell your gear › Indianapolis, IN
Sell Your Gear in Indianapolis: Stores That Buy & Trade
5 stores in Indianapolis, Indiana show real evidence of buying, trading, or consigning used gear — 5 with it confirmed on the store's own site — guitars, basses, amps, pedals, the lot. The process is the easy part: walk in with the instrument, let their buyer look it over, get a quote — usually one number for cash and a higher one for trade credit (shops often go around 20% higher in credit, since it keeps the money in the building). The part worth doing right is the comparison: with 5 buying stores in town, a second quote is a short drive away, and it's the single best negotiating tool you have. Stores are ranked below by local reputation (rating weighted by review count), and where players' reviews talk about trade-ins and offers, the quote is shown — that's the reputation you're choosing between.
4. Arthur's Music Store
4.7 ★★★★★ 250 reviews
Selling gear in Indianapolis: the short checklist
- Call before you carry. "Do you buy used gear, and is your buyer in today?" takes thirty seconds. Some shops quote any hour they're open; at others, the person who writes the numbers keeps their own schedule.
- Show up with the sellable version. Wipe it down, fresh strings if it's a guitar, original parts back on (bring any swapped parts in the case pocket — they count), and bring the case. Clean, original, and cased is gear the shop can hang tomorrow, and the quote says so.
- Know your number before they say theirs. Look up what your model actually sells for used, then expect the offer to land well below it — that gap is the shop's margin and risk, not an insult. Roughly half to two-thirds of street value is normal territory; fast-moving models quote at the high end.
- Ask for both numbers. Cash and trade credit — the credit number is usually meaningfully higher (around 20% more is common). If your next purchase is inevitable anyway, credit is the better math; if you just want out, take the cash.
- Get the second quote. 5 stores in town buy gear, and they know it. "Any room on that?" plus a competing number across town is the entire negotiation — polite, expected, and it works. For high-end or vintage pieces, also ask about consignment: slower money, but usually more of it.
All guitar stores in Indianapolis, IN → · All sell-your-gear cities →