HomeNew YorkHuntington › Vintage Guitar Gallery of Long Island

Vintage Guitar Gallery of Long Island

4.7 ★★★★★ 23 Google reviews · Guitar & music store in Huntington, New York

Buys used gear Vintage specialist Repairs & setups

Plan your visit

  • Repairs & setups a repair bench comes up in reviews and the store's own info — call ahead for turnaround, since good techs run a queue
  • Buys & trades used gear they buy, trade, or consign used instruments — bring the case and any original parts, and expect trade credit to beat the cash offer
  • Today see hours ·
  • Phone (516) 216-9889
  • Website vintageguitarsli.com

Hours

Monday 10 AM–6 PM
Tuesday 10 AM–6 PM
Wednesday 10 AM–6 PM
Thursday 10 AM–6 PM
Friday 10 AM–6 PM
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed

Hours can shift for holidays, clinics, and lesson schedules — worth a quick check before a special trip.

What's on the wall

Instrument and gear categories at Vintage Guitar Gallery of Long Island, confirmed in players' own reviews and the store's own info — not guessed from the sign out front.

🎸 Electric Guitars 2 mentions

“Kudos for an outstanding setup on my Gibson Custom Shop '59 Les Paul.”

All stores with electric guitars →

🔊 Amps & Pedals 7 mentions

“I recently purchased a Sho~Bud volume pedal from them that was the perfect candidate for a restoration.”

All stores with amps & pedals →

🏆 Vintage & Rare 19 mentions

“2002 Martin D-17 I happened to stumble across this guitar at Vintage Guitar Gallery of Long Island while doing related searches on the internet.”

All stores with vintage & rare →

🔧 Repairs & Setups 3 mentions

“Kudos for an outstanding setup on my Gibson Custom Shop '59 Les Paul.”

All stores with repairs & setups →

🎓 Lessons

“I took it to a lesson I had today and the teacher just said "O My ,O My,O My"when I opened the case.”

All stores with lessons →

Brands they deal

Brands players name in their reviews of Vintage Guitar Gallery of Long Island — the fastest way to tell what's actually hanging on the wall before you drive over.

🏷️ Fender

Who else deals Fender →

🏷️ Gibson 5 mentions

“The 1963 J 50 Gibson I purchased from Michael at the Vintage Guitar Gallery of Long Island was an absolutely outstanding great decision.”

Who else deals Gibson →

🏷️ Gretsch

Who else deals Gretsch →

🏷️ Epiphone

Who else deals Epiphone →

🏷️ Rickenbacker

Who else deals Rickenbacker →

Brand mentions are mined from reviews and the store's own info — they tell you what's on the wall, not formal authorized-dealer status. If warranty coverage matters, confirm dealer status with the store or the brand's own dealer locator.

What players say again and again

The things reviewers bring up again and again across 23 Google reviews — with their own words as proof.

🔧 expert setups & repairs 3 mentions

“Kudos for an outstanding setup on my Gibson Custom Shop '59 Les Paul.”

🧠 knowledgeable staff 5 mentions

“He is courteous and knowledgeable about his business and will get you the best price for your instrument.”

From the reviews

I really enjoyed my transaction with the Vintage Guitar Gallery of Long Island. I recently purchased a Sho~Bud volume pedal from them that was the perfect candidate for a restoration...it was missing a few things, that I so happened to have and could fabricate myself, so, I shot them an offer, and they accepted!

★★★★★ — Edward, Jan 2017

As a lefty buying a guitar is hard, and I am almost always buying blind online. I recently purchased a vintage Martin D-35 L from Vintage Guitar and I was blown away by what I received, low action, good intonation, no fret buzz, balanced tone -- and the guitar booms.

★★★★★ — Sean, Mar 2019

I have bought a 1956 Gibson LG1 and a 1970 Gibson ES335 from them. The prices were fantastic and the guitars just perfect (much better deals than one would get in the vintage guitar shops on Manhattan). The owner Michael Rudes is a very competent and reliable dealer.

★★★★★ — Erik, Dec 2017

An awesome Les Paul Guitar ! Great communication...I would do business with Michael again anytime ! Thank you. Dave.

★★★★★ — Dave, Jun 2018

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 23 reviews →

Selling or trading gear at Vintage Guitar Gallery of Long Island

Vintage Guitar Gallery of Long Island comes up for buying and trading used gear — confirmed on their own site. Two things make the trip go better. First, bring the whole package: the case or gig bag, the original tremolo arm or bridge parts, the paperwork if you have it — a complete rig is worth real money more than a bare instrument, and it saves the back-and-forth of "can you bring the case in?" Second, know that trade credit almost always beats the cash offer, usually by a healthy margin — if you're upgrading anyway, price your old gear as a trade against the new one before you take cash. Either way, expect the offer to be below what the gear sells for on the wall; the gap is the store's margin for setup, warranty, and sitting on it until the right buyer walks in.

Check trade-in info on their site

Where to find Vintage Guitar Gallery of Long Island

315 Main St 2nd Floor, Huntington, NY11743

Get directions Instagram · Facebook

Guitar stores near Vintage Guitar Gallery of Long Island

The Long Island Violin Shop

4.7 ★★★★★ 57 reviews

8 Elm St, Huntington, NY

Buys used gear Lessons Repairs & setups Vintage specialist knowledgeable staffgreat lesson programplays well with beginners

Store for the purchase, rental, and repair of stringed instruments, also offering music lessons.

under a mile away

Charles J. Rufino Violin Maker

8 Elm St, Huntington, NY

Vintage specialist

under a mile away

NY Music Garage

4.9 ★★★★★ 37 reviews

372 New York Ave, Huntington, NY

Lessons Repairs & setups expert setups & repairsknowledgeable stafffriendly staff

under a mile away

All guitar stores in Huntington, NY →

Listing verified July 2026 from public business records and player reviews. Something out of date? Report a correction. Own this store? Claim your listing — it's free.